35 Christmas Cookies You Need To Try

There are so many Christmas cookies to try, and in this article, we’ll help you find just the right ones for you.

After all, you need to have those cookies to snack on for the holiday season. It’s how the cookie crumbles.

35 Christmas Cookies You Need To Try

But you may find that you’ve become spoiled for choice. If so, let’s give you a choice of 35 Christmas cookies that you can narrow down. Then, you’ll be able to find the perfect treat for you and your family this winter.

So, let’s look at what we can offer you today!

1. Amish Sugar Cookies

These Amish sugar cookies are a favorite that has been around since the 1700s, and you can easily jazz up this recipe with some sprinkles.

They stand out as a traditional recipe that isn’t too chewy or crispy. There’s something about these vanilla-flavored cookies that are just right when it comes to flavor.

2. Candy Cane Cookies

Candy canes are one of my favorite treats at Christmas, so it’s no surprise that I adore these candy cane cookies.

They can even be hooked over a cup of hot cocoa, ready to be dipped in! What more could you ask for?

3. Candy Cane Kiss Cookies

These candy cane kiss cookies are easy to make, with just a bag of Hershey’s Candy Cane Kisses and some chocolate chips.

These are an addictive treat for the whole family during the holidays!

4. Chocolate Chip Cut Out Cookies

Look, you can’t have a list for Christmas cookies without including this age-old classic. Chocolate chip cookies are easy to make, and they’re easy to decorate too!

It’s a classic that’s well-loved for a reason, and you can always add some festive flair with different cut outs.

5. Christmas Chocolate-Covered Pretzel Rods

Do you want a quick and easy treat for your family this holiday? Maybe you want a nice easy gift to put in a bouquet?

Then I have some great news: these Christmas pretzel rods are an amazing gift for anyone who may receive them. With these, you’re guaranteed a hit!

6. Christmas Lights Cookies

While these won’t officially light up, everyone else’s faces will when you bring out these cookies. You just need icing and mini M&Ms to decorate these delicious treats!

7. Christmas Pinwheel Cookies

While you can enjoy these any time of year, you may find that you’ll enjoy them most at Christmas. These look like they’ve jumped straight out of a Dr. Seuss book.

Just roll the dough together and slice up however many cookies you’d like!

8. Christmas Tree Meringues

Take your Christmas tree cookies to the next level with these Christmas tree meringues! Pipe the green meringue, dip them in sprinkles, and decorate them however you like!

These meringues will be a perfect treat at any Christmas party.

9. Cinnamon Cream Cheese Cookies

These cream cheese cookies add to the holiday spirit with the amount of cinnamon used.

The cinnamon coating adds to the flavor, and the chewy texture of the cream cheese only adds to it! The outside does have more of a crunch, but that only adds to this delicious treat.

10. Cornflake Wreaths

These cornflake wreaths are easy to decorate and almost identical to the real thing! Use the texture of the cornflakes to make it look like there are real leaves on your wreath.

To stick them all together, use some marshmallows too!

11. Cut Out Sugar Cookies

Many childhood memories are filled with making cookies with parents or grandparents, which can be a great way to spend time with the kids.

Cut out different shapes for your sugar cookies to get the kids involved, and you’ll be able to enjoy these chewy cookies in a variety of different shapes and sizes.

12. Danish Butter Cookies

Danish butter cookies are a popular treat. You’ll only need four essential ingredients. You won’t need any eggs.

Get your butter, powdered sugar, vanilla extract, and all-purpose flour.

Cook them until they’re golden brown, and you’ll be able to enjoy these delightful treats with your family.

13. Eggnog Cookies

You can’t enjoy Christmas without some eggnog. So, try out this eggnog cookie recipe to incorporate this festive favorite into your holiday treats.

The best part about this recipe is that you can use whatever eggnog brand you like, so pick your favorite and let loose!

Once you’re done, you’ll be able to have your eggnog cookies and should taste a dash of cinnamon with them.

14. Gingerbread Cookies

You can make your gingerbread cookies however you prefer, as little men, as tree decorations, or make up an entire house for them.

The important thing is that gingerbread cookies are super easy to make and are perfect for decorating. They’re one of the best activities to participate in with the kids!

15. Grinch Cookies

Grinch cookies are a popular holiday favorite. While the Grinch may hate Christmas, no one can hate these delicious treats.

Get some vanilla cake mix and food coloring to seal the deal with these treats.

16. Hot Cocoa Cookies

Nothing is better than curling up in front of your tree with some hot cocoa in your hands, but I can add to this by suggesting these Hot Cocoa cookies that even include the hot cocoa mix to the cookies.

Grab some chocolate chips and some mallow bits to get that same feeling as drinking hot cocoa in the evening.

17. Italian Christmas Cookies

These Italian Christmas cookies are a popular treat to serve with either espresso or wine (for more Italian Christmas desserts, read here).

The colors for these cookies are a surefire way of seeing just how sweet these cookies are, and the best thing is that despite their crunchy exterior, their interior remains soft.

They’re popular in Italy, and it’s no surprise they’ve become more popular worldwide.

18. Italian Fig Cookies

As part of a family recipe passed down through generations, we’re lucky enough to have this recipe shared online with the rest of the world.

Figs are a popular treat at Christmas, so it’s no surprise they’ve been incorporated into this great treat!

19. Melted Snowman Cookies

Snow at Christmas time is something everyone hopes for, but that’s not always the case. If you want to build a snowman, try out this recipe for some snowman cookies before they all melt completely!

Just a warning, these will melt in your mouth, so keep that in mind if you get too attached to the snowmen.

20. Milk Snowballs

Made with sweetened condensed milk, these snowballs are an easy and budget-friendly recipe for you to try during the holidays.

The best thing about this recipe is that it’s customizable, so you can add in whatever favorite add-ons, be it cranberries, raisins, or chocolate chips.

You could leave them plain and enjoy these cookies’ soft, sweet texture.

21. Mince Pinwheels

If you’re anything like me, then Christmas is a time for mince pies. But if you’re not up for mince pies, then I have an alternative for you.

Try these mince pinwheels. Just spread the mince over your pastry and roll it all together. It’s such a simple recipe and so delicious too!

22. Mom’s Christmas Jello Balls

While not the traditional Christmas cookie you expected, this is a unique twist to a family’s traditional recipe.

These jello balls come in two different flavors and are colored both green and red to tie in with the Christmas spirit.

If you want an easy way to make a cookie without the hassle of baking, then take a seat and try some of these Christmas jello balls.

23. Oreo Christmas Pudding Cookies

If you want a quick cookie fix, then look no further! Grab a bag of Oreos, and you can easily dip these in white chocolate and icing.

Once you do this, they’ll look just like miniature Christmas puddings.

24. Peppermint Chocolate Thumbprint Cookies

Peppermint chocolate thumbprints are a delicious recipe. If you’ve got some white chocolate Hershey’s Kisses lying around, gather them to add to your tray.

They’re easy to make and go with just about any other treat you can think of!

25. Peppermint Oreo Crunch Cookies

Load these cookies up with chunks of cookies and peppermint chips, and you’ll find that your family and friends won’t be able to get enough of them.

You can start these out with a box recipe, too, as vanilla cake mix works brilliantly with this easy to make recipe.

26. Red Velvet Crinkles

A winning combination of the classic flavors and colors of Christmas. Just add a sweet dusting, and you’ve got some beautiful cookies you may not want to eat.

But don’t worry too much about looking at them, as they’ll vanish quickly!

27. Santa And Snowman Ice Cream Cookies

If you don’t want to feel like winter, try these Santa and snowman ice cream cookies to get that sweet summer feeling! These are both easy to make and delicious too!

28. Snowflake Cookies

No snowflake looks the same, so remember this as you work on your delicious snowflake cookies.

Have fun piping different designs on the icing and put your own unique and fanciful twists on your Christmas cookies this year.

29. Snow Globe Cookies

Are you ready to take your baking to the next level? Then have a look at taking a chance on these snow globe cookies.

Snow globes are a popular ornament, and these cookies are both beautiful to look at and delicious to eat.

Don’t worry, though, if you’re worried because we won’t be throwing you into the deep end here instead, the globe itself is just a handy addition to the cookie’s appearance.

30. Sprinkled Stocking Cookies

Check your stockings in the morning, and feast on these stocking sugar cookies during the day! These are easy cookies to make, and you must ensure that your family enjoys them!

31. Stained Glass Cookies

If you want to add some class to your sugar cookies, why not try out these stained glass cookies? They’re still easy to make, and the stained glass is made from candy.

This is a perfect, unique recipe to enjoy and give as a gift.

32. Ugly Christmas Sweater Cookies

There’s a longstanding tradition where you must wear ugly Christmas sweaters during the holidays.

But what’s stopping you from designing your own ugly Christmas sweater cookies? Let loose, grab a sweater cookie cutter, and have fun creating your own!

33. Whipped Shortbread Cookies

These light and airy treats have a buttery flavor that will melt in your mouth. They’re a soft treat, and you can lightly sprinkle them with sugar, icing, and sprinkles to add more to the flavor.

Unlike regular shortbread, whipped shortbread is far lighter and fluffier.

34. White Chocolate Candy Cane Cookies

White chocolate always makes me think of snow, and candy canes definitely can’t be avoided in my home during the holiday season.

It’s a great twist on some classic chocolate chip recipes, with the peppermint flavor melding perfectly with the chocolate.

35. White Chocolate Cranberry And Pistachio Cookies

If you ever look for any cookies in the Christmassy colors you know and love, then don’t hesitate to try these white chocolate cranberry and pistachio cookies.

But cherries work as a wonderful replacement if you don’t have cranberries on hand.

Final Thoughts

Here are all the Christmas cookie options we have available for you!

These delicious recipes are a guaranteed hit for the holiday season, so why not try them out, so you’re prepared for the holiday season?

Frequently Asked Questions

What Type Of Cookie Is A Christmas Cookie?

Most people typically see Christmas cookies as plain vanilla cookies with some icing. Usually, they’re cut out into different Christmas-themed shapes.

How Long Do Christmas Cookies Stay Fresh?

The best thing to do is seal any Christmas cookie in an airtight container. That way, you can ensure they stay fresh for around two weeks.

However, this depends on the cookie, so make sure you know just what type you plan on cooking and check the storage instructions in your recipe. 

Can I Store Cookies In Ziploc Bags?

You can store cookies in airtight containers, including Ziploc bags, to ensure they stay fresh. 

Can I Freeze Christmas Cookies?

You can freeze most Christmas cookies so long as they’re kept in the right container. You can wrap them in plastic wrap to ensure they don’t get freezer burns.

35 Christmas Cookies You Need To Try

35 Christmas Cookies You Need To Try

Recipe by Jenna

Everybody loves Christmas cookies, but do you realize how many types are out there? Try out the recipes we gathered for this holiday season.

Course: Appetizers
5 from 1 vote
Follow Me
Latest posts by Jenna (see all)