23 Of The Most Scrumptious Sugar-Free Pies On The Net!

If, like many of us, you have a sweet tooth and love to sink your teeth into a delicious pie, you may well have a few good ideas already.

Contents show

However, if you are a diabetic, or perhaps on the borderline to becoming one, or if you simply want to watch your blood sugar levels, so you don’t get sudden spikes, then you should turn your attention to pies that are sugar-free.

23 Of The Most Scrumptious Sugar-Free Pies On The Net!

Fortunately, there are some really great sugar-free pies out there that taste amazing, and aren’t too difficult to make. Some of them can even be eaten on the keto diet.

In this article, you will find my handpicked shortlist of 23 of the best sugar-free pie recipes on the internet today. Then at the end, I’ll throw in a section where I answer your most frequently asked questions on the subject.

And without further ado, prepare for mouth to start watering because here we go!

1. No Sugar Apple Pie Recipe From All Recipes

I thought I would kick things off with a wholesome take on a good old American classic.

This apple pie is naturally sweet and contains no added sugar. It is made with 5 simple ingredients, namely apple slices, sugar-free pie crusts, cornstarch, unsweetened apple juice concentrate, and ground cinnamon.

It’s one of the most popular sugar-free apple pie recipes on the net, and with good reason too!

2. Sugar Free Blueberry Pie Recipe From The Sugar Free Diva

I just love the modest, understated flavor of blueberries. It has a subtle taste that’s not too rich, and always goes down well.

It’s made with just 5 ingredients, namely a ready-made pie crust, fresh blueberries, flour, artificial sweetener, and lemon juice.

The recipe yields 10 servings and is ready to eat in just under an hour. What’s more, it’s only 143 calories per slice!

3. Healthy Sugar Free Sweet Potato Pie Recipe From The Foodie Affair

Potatoes in a dessert dish? Well, I can tell you from experience, sweet potato works in a dessert – it tastes GOOD!

It features easy to source ingredients such as butter, eggs, and heavy cream. And there are other flavorful ingredients such as vanilla extract, golden monk fruit, and pumpkin pie spice.

When baked and cooled, I recommend topping it with whipped cream and more pumpkin spice or ground nutmeg to serve!

4. Keto Sugar-Free Pecan Pie Recipe From Wholesome Yum

If you like to sink your teeth into a pie with some real crunch, then this recipe could be exactly what you’re looking for.

It’s made with the likes of an almond flour or coconut flour pie crust, butter, heavy cream, maple syrup, vanilla extract, and, of course, coarsely chopped pecan nuts.

It’s so low in carbs you can even enjoy it on the keto diet, and it’s easy to make to boot!

5. Homemade Sugar Free Peach Pie Recipe From The Sugar Free Diva

If you fancy a fruit pie and want to try your hand at making your own sugar-free pie crust, then you should certainly consider this recipe.

Besides the pie crust, you only need 6 ingredients, namely pitted peach slices, lemon juice, erythritol, Surkin gold, cornstarch and ground nutmeg.

The recipe yields 10 servings and can be ready to eat in just over an hour.

6. No-Bake Chocolate French Silk Pie For One Recipe From Gnom Gnom

OMG, this recipe is amazing!

It’s so decadent and indulgent, you can barely believe it’s so low in carbs that it’s considered keto-friendly. And it also happens to be gluten-free and paleo-friendly.

It’s made with the likes of almond flour for the keto “Oreo” pie crust, and instant coffee, coconut milk, cocoa powder, and vanilla extract.

There’s no baking required, and the chocolate filling comes out silky smooth.

7. Gluten Free Keto Banoffee Pie Recipe From Sugar Free Londoner

While bananas are normally considered high in carbs, albeit with a low GI score, this recipe uses banana extract rather than actually bananas.

And you don’t have to worry about high carbs in the pie crust either because it’s made with almond flour.

The filling is made with butter and heavy cream, and the topping is made with whipped heavy cream, vanilla and sweetener, and a sprinkling of dark chocolate shavings.

8. Keto Chocolate Pie With A Pecan Crust Recipe From Kasey Trenum

This chocolate pie is quite the crowd pleaser!

The filling features a wonderfully light yet creamy chocolate mousse, in a delightfully crunchy pecan pie crust. There’s also a lovely whipped cream topping made with heavy cream and artificial sweetener.

And, it’s so low in carbs that it’s approved on the keto diet. It does take some time to make, but it’s 100% worth the wait.

9. Keto Lemon Meringue Pie Recipe From The Big Man’s World

Lemon has such a bright and fresh flavor, and it tastes amazing in this dessert. What’s more, this is a super simple recipe to make.

All you need are 5 ingredients, namely a keto graham cracker crust, keto lemon curd, egg whites, powdered artificial sweetener, and optional cream of tartar.

The recipe yields 12 servings, each coming in at just 175 calories. And the whole thing is ready to eat in as little as 10 minutes.

10. Keto Peanut Butter And Chocolate Pie Recipe From I Breathe I’m Hungry

I just love the combination of peanut butter and chocolate – divine!

This recipe features a delicious chocolate and almond flavor crust. Then there’s a scrumptious filling made with sugar-free creamy peanut butter, mascarpone cheese, and vanilla extract.

And the topping is just as amazing, with 90% chocolate squares, more sugar-free peanut butter, heavy whipping cream, and chopped salted peanuts!

11. Refined Sugar-Free Cherry Pie Recipe From Fitty Foodilicious

This delicious recipe features fresh cherries, and uses coconut sugar instead of refined white sugar.

You don’t have to worry about making your own pie crust dough because you can use store-bought.

And it’s a fun recipe to make because you get to weave pastry strips over the top of the filling.

It takes a while to make, but it’s certainly worth waiting for.

12. Sugar-Free Keto Coconut Cream Pie Recipe From Sweet As Honey

If you love the taste of coconut, then this is the recipe for you – even the pie crust is coconut flavored!

There’s a wonderful coconut cream filling made with the likes of heavy cream, butter, coconut milk, coconut and vanilla extracts, and shredded coconut.

And it features a sweet topping made with heavy whipping cream, powdered artificial sweetener, and more vanilla extract.

13. Keto Pistachio Pudding Pie Recipe From I Breathe I’m Hungry

This dish is a pistachio lover’s dream!

The pie crust is made with keto-friendly pistachio shortbread cookie dough. The filling is made with sugar-free pistachio pudding mix, alongside the likes of almond milk, mascarpone cheese, heavy whipping cream and vanilla extract.

And of course, it also gets topped with extra chopped pistachios for a fitting garnish.

The recipe yields 12 servings and is ready to eat in just over half an hour.

14. Sugar Free Strawberry Pie Recipe From Mom Loves Baking

This is a super simple recipe – you only need 5 ingredients. What’s more, it’s both sweet and sugar-free at the same time.

All you need to make it is a suitable pie crust, water, fresh strawberries, cornstarch, and sugar-free gelatin. You can also make pretty heart shapes with the dough to go around the edges!

It yields 12 servings at just 204 calories each, and is ready to eat in just 38 minutes.

15. Sugar Free Key Lime Jello Pie Recipe From The Sugar Free Diva

I just love this take on a key lime pie! And it couldn’t be any simpler to make – you only need 5 ingredients.

All you have to do is dissolve some sugar-free lime flavored jello, stir in some ice water until melted, stir in some whipped topping, and refrigerate until thickened.

When ready, simply transfer the filling to a prepared pie crust, and top with some fresh lime zest and wedges to serve!

16. Low Sugar Raspberry Pie Recipe From Sweet Smart

This wonderfully fruity dessert is not only low in sugar and carbs, but it can be made ready to eat in under an hour.

It’s made with real raspberries, fresh or frozen, standard pie crust dough, unsweetened applesauce, tapioca flour, and some ground cinnamon for a hint of spice.

It’s sumptuous, fruity and mildly sweet. The recipe yields one 9-inch pie, and each serving comes in at 330 calories.

17. Keto Peanut Butter Pie Recipe From That Low Carb Life

This peanut butter pie is to die for!

It features a scrumptious no-bake pie crust, made with cocoa powder and almond flour, which acts as the base for the creamiest peanut butter flavor filling. 

The filling itself requires just 5 ingredients, namely cream cheese, peanut butter, powdered artificial sweetener, heavy cream and vanilla extract.

It tastes great topped with a drizzle of chocolate sauce!

18. Keto Raspberry Cream Pie Recipe From My Keto Kitchen

I just love this dish! You’ve got a really nice low-carb almond and chocolate cookie pie crust, followed by a layer of filling, made with the likes of cream cheese, heavy cream, sugar-free Jello, vanilla extract, and sugar-free chocolate chips.

Then for the topping you’ve got regular heavy cream, without any added confectioner’s sugar. I love to serve it with slices of fresh strawberries.

19. Sugar-Free Blackberry Custard Pie Recipe From Low Carb Maven

Not only is this pie delicious and low-carb, it’s also unbelievably quick to make – you can have it ready to eat in under half an hour.

It’s loaded with fresh, juicy blackberries, combined with buttermilk, heavy cream, low-carb sugar, gelatin powder, vanilla extract, and a pinch of ground nutmeg.

The pie crust is also low-carb, as it’s a keto-friendly graham cracker pie crust.

20. Keto Pumpkin Pie Recipe From Gnom Gnom

This low-sugar alternative to a traditional pumpkin pie is perfect for Thanksgiving!

It features a keto-friendly pie crust, while the pumpkin pie recipe is made with the likes of pumpkin purée, heavy cream, vanilla extract and spices such as cinnamon, cloves, ginger and nutmeg.

The recipe yields 10 servings at just 288 calories each.

21. Sugar Free Blueberry Pie Recipe From The Sugar Free Diva

This is a super simple recipe to make, and I just love how fruity it tastes.

You only need 5 ingredients to make it altogether, namely a pre-made pie crust, some fresh blueberries, some flour, some artificial sweetener, and some lemon juice.

The recipe makes 10 servings, coming in at just 143 calories each, and is ready to eat in under an hour.

22. Low Carb Sugar Free Chocolate Cream Pie Recipe From My Kitchen Escapades

You just can’t go wrong with a classic chocolate pie! And this one is sugar-free and requires just 4 ingredients in total, namely an almond based pie crust, sugar-free instant chocolate pudding, skim milk and heavy whipping cream.

I also like to throw in some sugar-free chocolate shavings as garnish.

23. Lemon Ricotta Pie Recipe From Joy Filled Eats

And now to go out with a bang! This delicious recipe is just so light and refreshing. Better yet, it takes less than 15 minutes prep time.

It has a low-carb pie crust, and a cheesecake-like filling featuring lemon juice and lemon zest. And you top it with fresh blueberries for a contrast of flavors and texture.

What’s more, it’s also sugar-free, grain-free and gluten-free to boot!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pie OK For Diabetics?

Pies are often a no-no for diabetics, since a flour pie crust and a sugary filling can really spike your blood sugar.

However, as the above shortlist of recipes shows, you can get sugar-free pies which won’t cause your blood sugar to spike, and therefore may be OK for diabetics to eat.

What Dessert Won’t Spike My Blood Sugar?

If you want to avoid a spike in your blood sugar, be sure to avoid desserts that are made with added sugar.

The best desserts to prevent a spike in blood sugar are high-protein ones, such as peanut butter based desserts.

What Can I Bake With Instead Of Sugar?

Here are some excellent substitutes for sugar in your baking:

Artificial sweeteners
Maple syrup
Fruit concentrates
Coconut sugar

Unfortunately, however, these substitutes are not necessarily perfect substitutes for sugar in every recipe, so proceed with caution.

Wrap Up

I hope you’ve enjoyed browsing through my shortlist of the best sugar-free pie recipes on the internet.

No doubt, at this point, you will find yourself tempted to try one or two of the recipes presented and are keen to have a go at making them. Enjoy!

23 Of The Most Scrumptious Sugar-Free Pies On The Net!

Recipe by Jenna
Course: Uncategorized
0 from 0 votes


  • Pick a recipe from above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review

Recipe Video

Follow Me
Latest posts by Jenna (see all)