The 16 Best Ice Cream Flavors You Can Get At Cold Stone Creamery

At some point on your travels, you may come across a Cold Stone Creamery and with so many different flavors, it helps to know which are considered the best ones.

Ice cream should be a treat so you do not want to miss the good stuff when you arrive in the store. You also do not want to hold up the line by spending a while trying to make your mind up as you may be overwhelmed simply by how many menu items there are and by the sheer number of possible combinations. 

Find out which flavors you should enjoy and you will not be disappointed. That could be something as simple as chocolate or coffee or something decidedly more extravagant like German chocolate cake, cake batter, cheesecake, apple pie, or cotton candy.

The 16 Best Ice Cream Flavors You Can Get At Cold Stone Creamery

There are also some seasonal favorites such as Pumpkin Cheesecake, though you could simply go for a Birthday Cake remix, even if it isn’t your special day. 

In this guide, we will look at 16 of the very best ice cream flavors you can get at Cold Stone Creamery.

You can even dip into their list of Signature Creations or create your very own unique blend of flavors from mix-ins and ice cream bases.

You may simply stick to your preferred flavors that have been developed since you were a child or want to try something new and unique. These flavors will include a range of textures and mix-ins so get ready to have your taste buds salivating. 

The 16 Best Ice Cream Flavors You Can Get At Cold Stone Creamery

  • Oreo Overload
  • Germanchökolätekäke
  • Cake Batter
  • Cheesecake Fantasy
  • Chocolate Devotion
  • Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake
  • Peanut Butter Cup Perfection
  • Coffee
  • Cotton Candy
  • Surrender To Strawberry
  • Classic Cookie Dough
  • French Vanilla
  • Sweet Cream
  • Apple Pie A La Cold Stone
  • Founder’s Favorite

What You Should Look Out For At Cold Stone Creamery

What You Should Look Out For At Cold Stone Creamery

Ice cream shops are undoubtedly some of the happiest places to visit, whether you need a pick-me-up or a treat. They can be ideal for a birthday, the holidays or a final destination to finish off a first date.

From their fresh ice cream that is made in store to their mixing on granite slabs, the mix-ins themselves and the entertainment factor. You are sure to have a great time and that’s not to mention their batter flavors and frozen yogurt. 

Fresh Ice Cream Made Every Day

One of the stand-out reasons to visit a Cold Stone Creamery is that their ice cream is so fresh as it is made daily.

Few ice cream shops can say that and, as such, the ice cream is classed as ‘super premium’ by the industry as it contains between 12 and 14% butterfat for a decadent and creamy texture.

The fact it is churned in each shop helps the ice cream become malleable and welcomes in any mix-ins you desire for your own unique concoction.

The Frozen Granite Slabs

Take a look at the frozen granite slabs the next time you are in a Cold Stone Creamery. Obviously, the slabs are there for a reason and are important as they help give the brand name its meaning.

There is also some science behind it as each granite slab is chilled to about 16°F to keep the ice cream cold and ready for mixing. If the ice cream is not as soft, it cannot be softened by a spatula.

When a customer requests a mix-in, the slab comes into its own as the ice cream is just the right temperature to be malleable.

The ice cream is dolloped on the slab and a well is made in the center with a spatula so the mix-ins can get mixed in properly as the mixture is folded and chopped until evenly incorporated. 

The Mix-Ins

Those mix-ins form part of Cold Stone Creamery’s core appeal as there are 30 to choose from. Again, this may seem daunting but it does mean you can create your own unique ice cream concoction.

That includes something as simple as fresh fruit but you can go extravagant with gooey brownies (even ask them to heat the brownie pieces up), caramel, sponge cake, pretzels, and graham cracker pieces. 

The Entertainment Factor

Another part of Cold Stone Creamery’s appeal is the entertainment delivered by their staff. Unlike a lot of ice cream shops, the staff are not expected simply to stand there and sullenly deliver ice cream all day.

The staff are called ‘sundae artists’ for a reason as they have to pass an interview with an enthusiastic performance. If they impress enough, they can contribute to the shop’s entertainment factor once they are hired.

That may even be a song if you offer a tip and staff have been known to come up with their own songs for a unique take on entertainment.

If you want to embarrass a family member or impress on a date then drop in some coins into the tip jar and watch them sing. 

The Batter Flavors

One of the main reasons why Cold Stone Creamery stands out from other ice cream shops is their range of batter flavors. This is good to know if you bake cakes at home and really enjoy licking the bowl.

That sweet, decadent taste of cake batter feels so wrong yet tastes so right, even if it does come with a risk of salmonella.

If you don’t want to risk abdominal cramps or diarrhea, try their Birthday Cake Remix flavor while the likes of Loaded Peanut Butter Batter, Everything’s Batter With Chocolate, and Rainbow Cookie Batter may be only available for limited periods. 

The Frozen Yogurt Bar

All that ice cream could be bad for you and if you struggle with moderation then try Cold Stone Creamery’s frozen yogurt bar.

FroYo is a relatively recent addition to the menu but still comes with all those toppings so you can still make it into your favorite treat, just without all the added calories.

The 16 Best Ice Cream Flavors You Can Get At Cold Stone Creamery

From cookies to German chocolate cake (see also ‘23 + Delicious German Cookie Recipes‘), cake batter and cheesecake to apple pie and cotton candy. You can spend time working your way through the menu at Cold Stone Creamery yet here are 16 of the best ice cream flavors. 

1. Oreo Overload

Oreos and milk go so well together so you really should try the Oreo Overload flavor from Cold Stone Creamery. This is effectively a mix of Sweet Cream flavored ice cream with chocolate chips, fudge, and a healthy portion of Oreo chunks to pull out.

Even Cold Stone admits that this is like dipping some Oreo cookies in milk yet the fudge and chocolate chips are welcome additions.

For anyone that is a fan of Sweet Cream flavor (more about that later), imagine that it is a glass of milk and the Oreos suddenly become a major part of the ice cream experience as a Signature Creation or something to enjoy at home. 

2. Germanchökolätekäke

Unless you took German at school, this flavor may be a mouthful to order but is well worth it for some delicious mouthfuls of ice cream.

German chocolate cake is undoubtedly one of the finer desserts on the planet so imagine it in ice cream form and you are off to a winning formula.

The ice cream flavor begins with a base of smooth, creamy chocolate ice cream which is then topped with coconut. Mixed in pecans creates a crunchy texture and brownies help deliver that moreishness. 

Most of the reasoning for Germanchökolätekäke being such a renowned flavor is due to how those different textures combine and work so well together. Yet the ice cream remains sweet and still reminds you of deeply delicious German chocolate cake. 

3. Cake Batter

If there is a flavor to define Cold Stone Creamery it is likely to be Cake Batter as you simply struggle to find it anywhere else and, if you do, it is unlikely to be as good.

Any home bakers who enjoy licking the bowl should know how delectable cake batter can be, similar to cookie dough in how wrong yet so right it can be.

That may be why one of the more popular mix-ins for Cake Batter is cookie dough. However, the Signature Creation will be Birthday Cake remix which is Cake Batter ice cream accompanied by brownies, sprinkles, and hot fudge. 

4. Cheesecake Fantasy

Some cheesecake ice-cream flavors are pale imitations when it comes to the real thing, but not Cheesecake Fantasy at Cold Stone Creamery.

That combination of blueberries, strawberries, graham cracker crust, and cheesecake ice-cream will fully make you believe you are digging into a fresh slice.

The tartness of the blueberries and strawberries combine really well with only slight sweetness creating a fresh and decadent ice cream flavor. Plus you get a fair amount of graham cracker pie crust for a varying biscuity, crumbly texture.  

5. Chocolate Devotion

Chocolate lovers will undoubtedly be pleased at the efforts Cold Stone Creamery have gone to with Chocolate Devotion. Not only is the ice-cream rich and thick but those chocolate flavors are boosted with brownie pieces, fudge, and chocolate chips.

Every single mouthful should have an element of chocolate and it can become overwhelmingly intense after a short time. Try a bit first yet if you cannot get enough chocolate then dive right in and enjoy.

6. Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip

Undoubtedly, the worst mint flavored ice cream can remind you of toothpaste yet Cold Stone Creamery has it down to a tee as this remains creamy with just a mint aftertaste.

If you want to extenuate the mint flavor then take it up to 11 with Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip which sounds like a mouthful but is well worth ordering.

This is a Signature Creation that mixes mint ice cream with brownies, fudge, and chocolate chips for just the right amount of mint with chocolate without being too overpowering.

If you want a little subtlety introduced then mix in some more chocolate as a solid option.

7. Pumpkin Cheesecake

Sure, Pumpkin Spice only seems to be available during Fall yet you should not struggle with that issue so much when it comes to the Pumpkin Cheesecake flavor.

In fact, if you like pumpkin then you can try their Pumpkin flavor which brings more of that fall flavor as opposed to the more seasonable spiced latte flavor.

Pumpkin Cheesecake is a little more subtle and can be a welcome way into the fall flavor. If you do try it, go for the graham cracker pie crust, coconut, cinnamon, whipped cream, caramel, and pecan mix-ins. 

8. Peanut Butter Cup Perfection

Peanut Butter Cup Perfection may be another of those flavors in rotation yet remains an exquisite blend of ice cream with a peanut butter cup.

Put simply, this is chocolate ice cream combined with peanut butter, fudge, and Reese’s peanut butter cups. If you love peanut butter then this is the flavor for you and is incredibly moreish.

This is a flavor that will undoubtedly stick with you too as the aftertaste is a strong peanut butter flavor, which is nothing to complain about. 

9. Coffee 

Some prefer to drink their coffee yet a lot of non-coffee drinkers swear by coffee as a bona fide winning ice cream flavor. The coffee ice cream from Cold Stone Creamery is made from real coffee making it far superior to any you can find in a store.

The flavor is also versatile enough to go with several combinations, as you expect from a cup of Joe with caramel to bring a deep saltiness which nicely rounds off the coffee notes.

There are two Signature Creations to choose from; Mud Pie Mojo and Coffee Lovers Only. 

Coffee Lover’s Only will come with almonds (be careful if you suffer from an allergy), caramel, and Heath Bar pieces.

This is the one for those coffee aficionados as it employs that rich bitterness, whether they prefer an after dinner corner or one first thing in the morning.

That should sound tempting enough yet Mud Pie Mojo typically comes with fudge, almonds, peanut butter, and Oreo cookies.

You may even find the Amaretto flavor which is a mixture of coffee and an amaretto shake alongside chocolate chips as the mix-in. 

10. Cotton Candy

Should you want to be reminded of a trip to the fairground then take a ride with Cold Stone Creamery’s Cotton Candy flavor.

Granted, it is allegedly all sugar, but you would expect that with a serving of real cotton candy so it avoids that artificial flavoring that can ruin a lot of cotton candy ice cream.

Plus, the Cotton Candy ice cream should be bright blue so it looks good on your socials. Mix it in with gummy bears for Beary Beary Blue and you have a favorite of kids and adults alike.

11. Surrender To Strawberry

Strawberry may be considered a classic flavor yet at Cold Stone Creamery it is ramped up to be the perfect mix of berry and creamy notes in Surrender To Strawberry.

If you enjoy strawberry-flavored milkshakes then be aware of how it tastes like strawberry even before the milk is mixed in.

That taste of fresh strawberries comes through good and true so you can even use Surrender To Strawberry as a sundae of choice which is essentially a strawberry ice-cream turned up to the max.

Imagine a graham cracker pie crust, strawberry ice cream, with moreish yellow cake chunks, fresh strawberries pieces with juice and a whipped cream topping. 

12. Classic Cookie Dough

For those who enjoy licking the bowl while baking, there is the Cake Batter flavor. For those who enjoy a nibble of the dough while creating cookies, there is the Classic Cookie Dough flavor.

This may prevent you from taking a nibble from the cookie dough tube in the fridge as it tastes just like cookie dough without making you think that you’re eating something that really should be cooked in the oven.

That’s right, that cookie dough flavor without the worry that you may be giving yourself salmonella.

13. French Vanilla

Should you enjoy the taste of frosting then the French Vanilla flavor may be right for you. Sure, vanilla can seem like a blasé flavor yet French Vanilla is a light and sweet variation on that classic flavor.

Plus, French Vanilla is versatile for a range of mix-ins as you can add virtually anything to it for your own twist. Try peanut butter and brownies for sheer decadence or mix in some tartness with raspberries or keep it mellow with some marshmallows. 

14. Sweet Cream

You may expect Sweet Cream simply to be yet another variation of classic vanilla just like French Vanilla, and to a large extent it is just that but remains a classic serving.

This is simply because it comes without the added vanilla flavoring so you can expect the purity of sugar, cream, and milk for a fresh flavor.

The reason why Sweet Cream is so decadent is due to Cold Stone Creamery’s formula of including between 12 and 14% of butterfat so you should not feel embarrassed to simply get a plain serving.

The beauty is that you can create your own twist with your mix-ins while being reassured that underneath it all is that Sweet Cream vanilla taste.

15. Apple Pie A La Cold Stone

Apple Pie A La Cold Stone regularly features highly in surveys of the best ice cream flavors you can get at Cold Stone Creamery. Rightfully so too as that graham cracker pie crust works so well with the apple pie filling.

The flavors begin with sweet yet subtle French Vanilla ice-cream to draw you in then there is that graham cracker pie crust followed by spicy cinnamon, moreish apple pie filling and dreamy caramel.

It is more about the blend that makes you believe you are eating a slice of pie and ice-cream that makes it rank so highly. 

16. Founder’s Favorite

Who better to trust to recommend the best ice cream flavor at Cold Stone Creamery than the founders themselves; Donald and Susan Sutherland.

Founder’s Favorite is Sweet Cream ice cream which is then mixed with fudge, caramel, pecans, and brownies.

However, you can swap out the ice cream flavor from Sweet Cream to whichever you want though the combination of ingredients works best with French Vanilla or Salted Caramel.

For an even greater mix, ask that the server warm up the brownie and that they use hot fudge rather than regular fudge. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Is It Easy To Mix Ice Cream Flavors When You Visit Cold Stone Creamery?

It should be easy to mix your favorite ice cream flavors to create a combination that you really enjoy.

Simply ask to order one of their Mix & Go containers and a server will fill it to the brim with your favorite flavors of ice cream and mix-ins so you can enjoy it at home.

Where Is Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Made?

This may be a surprise but all of Cold Stone Creamery is made fresh in the store. That’s right, it’s not delivered in on trucks but made fresh every day.

The ice cream is churned using the finest ingredients and then mixed with the candy, cakes, nuts, or fruit that you choose on a frozen granite stone. This should be the best made-to-order ice cream you can find anywhere. 

Final Thoughts

With so many flavors to choose from, it is relatively easy to become overwhelmed as soon as you enter a Cold Stone Creamery.

If you have a basic idea of the flavors you know you will like, such as chocolate, fruit, or mint, then ask for a small sample.

You may find that the flavor is just about right but it just needs the right texture, in which case you can add a mix-in and there are 30 to choose from.

Ordering an ice-cream should be fun so try not to feel overwhelmed, do your research and try to find a welcome contrast of flavors with the right consistency and you should be off to a winner.

Follow Me
Latest posts by Jenna (see all)