13 Authentic Amish Bread Recipes You Are Going To Love

Amish bread comes from the Amish people, and it is typically served at the dinner table as a side dish to the main course. Though it began as a staple food for this group of people, it has grown in popularity with people outside of the community. 

13 Authentic Amish Bread Recipes You Are Going To Love

Amish bread is usually made with easy-to-source and simple ingredients, which is one of the big reasons why it’s so popular. It’s cheap and easy to make, and it tastes absolutely delicious! 

If you want to try some Amish bread for yourself, then you have come to the right place! We will be taking a look at 13 authentic and delicious Amish bread recipes that you are going to absolutely love.

1. Amish Sourdough Bread

First on the list, we have this delicious Amish bread that is made in the style of sourdough. Amish Sourdough Bread is also known as Friendship Bread, so if you see this name, always remember it’s made with sourdough!

This recipe is simple to follow and will produce a deliciously soft and fluffy sourdough loaf that pairs beautifully with any main course you make.

Whether you love sourdough or this is your first time trying it, this is a great recipe for you to enjoy. 

2. Amish White Bread

Also known as “no-fail Amish white bread”, this is a great recipe to make if you’re new to making bread. As the name would suggest, it’s practically impossible to fail at making this recipe, which makes it perfect for new bakers. 

You only need 8 ingredients in total to make this recipe and the results are absolutely delicious. This Amish bread takes less than three hours to make as well, which is quite efficient timing for bread! 

3. Honey Whole Wheat Bread

This recipe is one of the longer ones on the list, so you will need to set aside quite a bit of time to make it, but we promise that it is totally worth it! This recipe produces a bread loaf that is beautifully soft, moist, and delicious.

You will love this recipe so much that you will find yourself making it again and again.

This is a versatile bread recipe as well because it pairs with practically any other food, so you will definitely want to hold on to this recipe. 

4. Amish Bread With Oatmeal

This recipe is great if you want to try Amish Bread made with oatmeal. It gives the bread a whole new texture that you will absolutely love. 

This is a really easy recipe to put together because you will be mixing all of the ingredients together in one bowl and then it will be ready to bake. If you’re looking for an easy, tasty, and different oatmeal recipe, you will love this one. 

5. Cinnamon-Sugar Amish Friendship Bread

This recipe takes classic Amish Friendship bread and makes it a bit sweeter by adding in some delicious cinnamon sugar. The cinnamon makes the bread taste even better and is filled with warm, comforting spices. 

This is a great bread to make when the weather gets colder and it works really well for the Fall and the holidays.

It’s quite a quick recipe as well (at least quick for bread!) so if you don’t have much time, you can whip this up and the whole family will love it!

6. Amish Potato Bread

This Amish potato bread recipe is a fantastic take on the classic Amish bread. It is super tender and moist on the inside with a delicious, flaky crust. 

It is similar in taste to wheat bread, but it’s a bit richer and sweeter. This is one of those recipes you will find yourself making again and again. It goes really well with practically every other food as well, so you can pair it with whatever you want. 

7. Amish Biscuits

This is a great recipe to have in your back pocket because it’s super easy to make and it gives you a little break from the classic bread recipe. You will be making traditional biscuits in an Amish style, and the results are absolutely incredible. 

You only need flour, buttermilk, butter, baking powder, sugar, and salt to make this recipe and it can be ready to serve in no more than 30 minutes! 

8. Amish Potato Rolls

Sometimes, a full-on loaf isn’t what you need, so rolls are always the next best thing! These potato rolls are light, soft, and full of flavor and they pair really well with whatever main course you are planning on making. 

These potato rolls might take a bit longer to make, but they are still super easy and you only need 10 ingredients in total to get going.

A fresh batch of Amish Potato Rolls is absolutely delicious and well worth the extra time it takes to make them. 

9. Amish Cornbread

Cornbread is a staple comfort food from the South, and this recipe combines that classic comfort with Amish-style baking to create a cornbread batch you won’t be able to get enough of. 

This cornbread is incredibly dense and crumbly and works especially well as a side dish to fill you up. It is super comforting and easy to make, and you will find yourself making this recipe again and again! 

10. Amish Onion Bread

If you want a bread recipe that is a bit more savory, then this Amish onion bread might be just what you are looking for!

This bread is incredibly light and fluffy on the inside and topped with intense and delicious flavors that get better with every bite. 

Just some of the ingredients you will be using for this bread include poppy seeds, onions, and paprika. These flavors come together to create a sensational combination of flavors that you won’t find anywhere else. 

This is a hearty Amish bread recipe you will definitely want to make again and again, so keep hold of this recipe once you’ve made it for the first time!

11. Amish Pumpkin Bread

If you want to find a more interesting pumpkin recipe ready for the Fall, then you definitely need to try this Amish pumpkin bread recipe! It is filled with delicious spices, such as cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, and ground ginger. 

These spices come together to give you a comforting and hearty loaf of bread that will keep you feeling warm as the nights get colder. 

The taste is absolutely amazing, but the smell is arguably better! Once it starts baking properly, you won’t be able to get enough of the smells that fill up your home!

12. Amish Apple Fritter Bread

If you have never tried apple fritter bread before, then you are definitely in for a treat! This apple fritter recipe follows the classic Amish bread tradition to create a delicious snack you will absolutely love. 

The crust is incredibly crunchy and crispy, while the inside is soft and moist. The apple filling is absolutely delicious as well. It is warm and filled with brown sugar and cinnamon which is absolutely to die for! 

This is an especially great recipe to make if you want to have something tasty and delicious for breakfast, and it pairs beautifully with both tea and coffee. 

13. Amish Friendship Bread

Of course, we could not make a list of Amish bread recipes without including a classic Friendship Bread recipe! All you need to bring this recipe to life is sugar, butter, eggs, buttermilk, flour, baking soda, and cinnamon.

This particular recipe is more sweet than savory, but once you try it for the first time, you will want to eat it again and again! 

Frequently Asked Questions

Why Is Amish Bread Called Amish Bread?

The reason it is called Amish bread is that it is a recipe that originates from the Amish people. Amish bread was created to be a simple, homemade bread that is served at the table for Amish families at mealtimes. 

Why Is My Amish Bread Dry?

If your Amish bread is too dry, this might actually be because there was originally too much moisture in the mix. When there is too much moisture in the Amish bread, it tends to dry out.

Always make sure you are using fresh ingredients, especially when it comes to yeast, baking soda, and baking powder. Non-fresh ingredients can also cause the bread to go dry. 

Does Amish Friendship Bread Need Refrigeration After Baking?

No, Amish Friendship bread does not need refrigeration after baking. Once the bread has cooled completely, you can store it in the same way you would store other homemade bread.

To keep it fresher for longer, make sure to keep it in an airtight container at room temperature. 


Amish bread is a fantastic type of bread that you definitely need to try if you haven’t already! Give some of these recipes a try for yourself and see which one you enjoy the most.

You definitely won’t be disappointed with any of these authentic Amish bread recipes once you’ve given them a try!

13 Authentic Amish Bread Recipes You Are Going To Love

13 Authentic Amish Bread Recipes You Are Going To Love

Recipe by Jenna

If you have never tried Amish Bread before then click here to learn about 13 authentic Amish Bread recipes you are absolutely going to love!

Course: Breakfast
0 from 0 votes


  • Pick a recipe from above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review

Recipe Video

Follow Me
Latest posts by Jenna (see all)