13 Tasty Replica Crumbl Cookie Recipes

Crumbl cookies are some of the softest and moistest cookies that you’ll ever try, but if you’re unsure what the Crumbl brand actually is, let us tell you a bit more about them.

13 Tasty Replica Crumbl Cookie Recipes

Crumbl Cookies burst onto the scene in 2017 and has grown exponentially since, opening in over 250 locations in the last few years.

We really recommend going to one of their locations to try how seriously delicious their sweet treats are, but if you can’t or just want to cook your own, here are 13 recipes that are replicas for Crumbl Cookies. 

1. Crumbl Chocolate Chip Cookies

A classic sweet treat that we’ve all come to love, surely it can’t be made any better, right? Well, Crumbl somehow manages to make this delicious dish taste even better.

These enormous, moist and chewy cookies (see also our favorite sugar-free cookies) will be the best ones you’ve ever had and with a total prep and bake time of an hour to make 24 cookies, what’s the reason not to bake them?

They’ll be a huge hit amongst whoever tries them and your baking skills will become the talk of the town.

2. Crumbl Peanut Butter Cookie

These are nothing like your average peanut butter cookie, they feature peanut butter in three different layers and the dough is soft and moist on the inside with just a touch of chewiness on the outside, this is the ultimate peanut butter cookie.

This recipe will only take 17 minutes of prep time, so not much effort is needed on your part and you’ll end up with 14 cookies at the end of it and of course you can freeze any leftovers for the next time your craving hits! 

3. Crumbl Red Velvet White Chocolate Chip Cookies

If you’ve never had a red velvet cookie before, you’re severely missing out, but the Crumbl version of a red velvet cookie is to die for.

Of course, these cookies don’t taste exactly like red velvet since no cream cheese icing or any vinegar or buttermilk (see also ‘The 35 Best Buttermilk Recipes To Try At Home‘) in the ingredients is used, but trust us when we say, they’re absolutely delicious.

The white chocolate chips add an extra sweet flavor and gooey goodness to the cookie, this is one of the easiest cookies on the list to make as it only calls for 11 ingredients. 

4. Crumbl Pink Velvet Cookies with Cream Cheese Icing

If you’re looking for a more authentic red velvet taste with the cream cheese icing (see also ‘28 Of The Most Delicious Cream Cheese Dessert Recipes‘), this recipe is for you. It lacks the chocolatey flavor that the red velvet cookies boast, but it makes up for it with its creamy and delicious cream cheese icing.

Instead of the chocolatey flavor, it showcases an earthy vanilla flavor, brown sugar and almond extract and of course, features the same buttery, crumbly texture that all the Crumbl cookies have.

This will only take 50 minutes out of your day, and creating the cream cheese icing is surprisingly easy, and don’t worry you don’t need to be a professional baker to ice these cookies. 

5. Crumbl Snickerdoodle Cupcake Cookies

Snickerdoodle cookies are hard to make better, they already taste amazing and are the perfect treat for a Fall night.

But Crumbl manages to make them taste so much more delicious by adding even more cinnamon and sugar and adding a tasty vanilla cream cheese frosting, which is why they have the name ‘cupcake cookies’.

Furthering the cupcake comparison, the cookies are so light and fluffy that it almost feels like you’re biting into a cupcake. You just have to make this recipe for the holiday season, it’ll be a smashing success!

6. Crumbl Lemon Glaze Cookies

If you’re looking for a treat that tastes like summer, these lemon glaze cookies have got you covered.

They’re bursting with lemon flavor, featuring a dough bursting with lemon-y flavor and a lemon glaze and if you want to go all out with the lemon flavor, place a slice of lemon on the top for good measure.

It’s super easy to make and you probably have all the ingredients sat in your pantry right now, so why not try baking this deliciously acidic cookie?

7. Crumbl Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie

This recipe features 2 amazing sweet treats into one, making the ultimate sweet treat.

These delicious cookies are made with a graham cracker bottom topped off with moist cream cheese frosting and drizzled with a perfect raspberry filling, these elements compliment each other so well.

Just be warned, once you start eating these delicious cookies, you won’t be able to stop!

They’re surprisingly easy to make and will only set you back around 37 minutes, including prep time and of course, you can always refrigerate or freeze them if you make too many. 

8. Crumbl Twix Cookies

Twix bars mixed with cookies, we’re in heaven! This cookie will quickly become your go to recipe, because who can say not to a soft sugar cookie stuffed with twix bars and topped with delicious caramel and creamy chocolate?

Seriously, they look so professionally done and taste like the real thing, you’ll only spend 30 minutes prepping these cookies and you’ll get a whopping 24 cookies from it that you can share around (or not, we won’t tell!). 

9. Crumbl Cosmic Brownie Cookies

Brownie cookies taste like something delivered from the gods themselves! These cookies taste just like brownies and they’re coated in creamy chocolate ganache, they taste absolutely divine and just having one won’t be enough.

For only 25 minutes out of your day, you’ll get 10 cookies in return and you can always refrigerate or freeze them if 10 ends up to be too many.

This recipe claims to be even better than Crumbl brownie cookies, and well, they might be right or even so, a very close second. 

10. Crumbl Sugar Cookies

Sometimes all you need to curb those sugar cravings is a simple sugar cookie, and Crumbl sugar cookies are without a doubt one of the best ones available right now.

So, what if we told you that these sugar cookies will be the easiest you’ll ever make? They feature a no chill dough that you don’t have to roll out, so you can have your cookies made in 30 minutes to quickly curb those sugar cravings.

These sweet and buttery cookies are topped with a delicious almond icing that is colored pink in authentic Crumbl style (though the coloring is optional). You’ll get 12 cookies from this recipe, but trust us, that won’t be enough! 

11. Crumbl Molten Lava Cookies

If the name of these cookies isn’t making your mouth water, we don’t know what will! These cookies feature the signature chewy, moist and buttery dough of all Crumbl cookies, but features a warm, gooey chocolate center, it’s pure bliss biting into them.

Molten lava cakes are notoriously finicky, but they’re made so much easier in cookie form, making this one of the most easy and delicious recipes that you’ll ever make! 

12. Crumbl Birthday Cake Cookie

Birthday cake has got to be one of the most popular flavors right now, and we can see why, who doesn’t love birthday cake?

It features sprinkles, funfetti and a delicious cake batter icing and a cake batter flavored cookie, trust us, it’ll feel like a celebration when you bite into one of these cookies!

They’re a perfect treat for an alternative to an actual birthday cake, or they’re perfect just as sweet treats for the whole family. 

13. Crumbl Cookie Dough Cookie

Is there anything better than a cookie that tastes just like cookie dough? These cookies have all the flavor of cookie dough, but with no raw eggs and they’re even topped with edible cookie dough bites!

The cookie itself is a brown sugar cookie and of course in typical Crumbl style, the dough is beautifully moist and crumbly.

These cookies are too good not to demolish in one sitting, luckily this recipe makes 24 cookies, so hopefully there will be plenty of cookies leftover for you to share, but we don’t blame you if you don’t! 

Frequently Asked Questions

How To Store Any Leftover Cookies

Each recipe will differ, and it should be stated on the recipe. But you can typically store these cookies in the refrigerator in an airtight container for up to a week, and they can be frozen in an airtight container for up to 3 months. 

Why Are My Cookies Too Crisp and Thin?

For Crumbl cookies, they need to be soft and chewy and also thick and pretty enormous!

So if your cookies are coming out crispy and thin, it’s usually a quick fix. It may be because there’s too much sugar in the dough, try switching to brown sugar as this results in a much thicker and chewier cookie, which is what Crumbl cookies are (see also ’11 Delicious Crumbl Cookies Flavors You Need to Try‘).

It could also be that the butter is too warm, causing the cookies to spread out more, resulting in thinner and flatter cookies. Another reason is the cookies could be overbaked. 

13 Tasty Replica Crumbl Cookie Recipes

13 Tasty Replica Crumbl Cookie Recipes

Recipe by Jenna

These copycat cookie recipes taste just like the originals. From snickerdoodle to chewy chocolate chip, you’ll find all the best recipes.

Course: Dessert
5 from 1 vote
Follow Me
Latest posts by Jenna (see all)