26 Mouth-Watering Bagel Sandwich Recipes

Essentially, a bagel is similar to a traditional sandwich with bread but much better! Unlike a bread sandwich, with a bagel, you get a soft, flavorful, chewiness that just enhances your sandwich experience.

With this in mind, we have compiled a list of some of the most insanely good bagel sandwich recipes. Whether you have been dreaming of bagels for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, well; your dreams are about to come true!

26 Mouth-Watering Bagel Sandwich Recipes

Don’t worry, there are many options for vegetarians, too! Including the egg salad bagel or the tomato and cream cheese bagel. 

There is a range of options that are sure to satisfy your cravings. Below, you will find 26 bagel sandwich recipes that you’re sure to love. Let’s get straight into it!

1. Hot Pastrami Bagel

If this classic New York bagel is great for new yorkers, then it’s good for you, too! You no longer need to travel to New York to get your bagel fix, when this hot pastrami bagel can be achieved straight from your kitchen.

Warm bagels are loaded with sliced pastrami, dill pickles, and mustard for the ultimate bagel.

2. Blueberry Grilled Cheese With Mascarpone And Brie

This blueberry bagel is perfect for any time of the day, whether this is for breakfast, lunch, or dinner – it is truly irresistible. 

If you’re wondering what a blueberry grilled cheese sandwich is, then you’re in for a delight!

To make the blistered berries, they are cooked over high heat with a spoonful of brown sugar until the berries explode which produces some juicy, mouthwatering deliciousness. 

To make it even better, you’ll want to pile your blistered blueberries onto a slathering of brie and mascarpone for the perfect balance of flavors. 

Add some fresh basil, then toast until the cheese has melted and you’re left with some gooey, melty goodness.

3. Everything Avocado Turkey Bagel Sandwich

This avocado turkey bagel sandwich is jam-packed with goodness and is the meal you’ve been waiting for all week.

The flavorful everything bagel is stacked high with avocado, meat, chipotle cream cheese, and roasted tomatoes. Not only is it healthy, but it is also insanely delicious.

Its protein-packed filling will ensure that you stay full until your next meal.

4. Everything Bagel Veggie Sandwiches

You don’t have to lose out on flavors and texture in vegetarian bagel sandwiches. Instead, try this recipe for a flavorful experience. 

A slightly toasted everything bagel is slathered in homemade garlic dill cream cheese and topped with your favorite crunchy vegetables. It is so good that you’ll want to eat it every day!

With only 15 minutes to prepare this meal, it’s a quick and easy meal for your lunch or breakfast- the choice is yours!

5. Spinach & Artichoke Bagel Melts

The perfect combination of three delicious ingredients: cheese, spinach, and artichoke. 

Toasted bagels are piled with creamy, gooey, and melty toppings. To understand just how good this recipe is, you’ll need to make it yourself!

6. Italian Salami Bagel Sandwich

This sandwich surpasses all other types of sandwiches, it’s the VIP of sandwiches. Do you think you can handle it?

This isn’t just any regular old bagel. It’s packed with four different types of meat, and cheese, and then drizzled with an Italian olive oil dressing.

7. Bruegger’s Blueberry Bagel French Toast

Looking for a sweet treat? Then you’re in the right place for one. You can’t beat this Bruegger’s blueberry bagel french toast!

Not only does it look extraordinary but it also tastes delicious! What we have here is blueberry bagels fried in French toast batter, then topped off with strawberry cream cheese and blueberry syrup. 

It is sure to satisfy those sweet tooths out there!

8. Avocado Egg Salad Bagel Sandwich

You can’t go wrong with an egg salad, but when put in a bagel sandwich; you’ll have yourself a mouthwatering masterpiece. 

You will want to start by making a classic egg salad, although; after this point you’ll find yourself a delicious twist.

Instead of making a regular egg salad, you’re going to take it up a notch by including fresh herbs, crunchy vegetables, and, of course, some avocado. 

Mash together the microgreen and cream cheese, and in just under 10 minutes, you should have yourself the best egg sandwich you have ever tasted – that is not an exaggeration!

9. The Ultimate Bagel Breakfast Sandwich

This bagel breakfast sandwich is the ultimate way to start your day. Whether you have a hard day of work ahead or just need a quick, portable pick-me-up, then you’re in the right place. 

With every bite, you’ll experience melty, cheese, a gooey fried egg, and crispy, salty bacon goodness. 

The secret to this bagel’s delicious flavors is all in the ingredients.

Thick sliced bacon is added for a punch of meatiness, while a sharp cheddar produces a more tangy taste, perfectly balancing out all the different flavors.

10. Cranberry Turkey Bagel

If you want it to feel like Christmas but without waiting, then you’re going to have to try this cranberry turkey bagel.

It’s no secret that turkey and cranberries are a perfect combination, the sweet, tangy flavorings work perfectly with the savory meat – especially in this recipe!

You’ll find stacked smoked turkey alongside cream cheese, red onion, and cranberry sauce. In each bite, you’ll experience a burst of textures and flavors.

11. Pizza Bagels

You can’t go wrong with pizza. However, when you cram all these delicious flavors and ingredients into a bagel, your taste buds will be thanking you for this deliciousness.

You’ll find all the traditional aspects you love about a pizza all in one place: the rich tomato paste, the meaty pepperoni, and, of course, the gooey, melty cheese. 

Depending on your dietary requirements, you can easily adjust this recipe to suit your personal needs.

For instance, try the Hawaiian style (see also ‘29 Amazing Hawaiian Recipes‘), simply skip the meat for a vegetarian version, or if you’re looking for an extra kick, try topping it off with some jalapenos. 

The possibilities are endless!

12. Roasted Red Pepper Pesto Chicken Bagel Sandwiches

This is the perfect prepare-and-pack sandwich for all your lunch requirements. 

Simply made from flavorful pesto, juicy chicken (see also ‘29 Best Chicken Dinner Ideas‘), fresh spinach, and red peppers – the perfect combination of flavors inside a bagel.

13. Everything Bagel BLT

This is the perfect combination of an everything bagel and a BLT sandwich. 

Fresh lettuce, tomato, and crispy bacon are served on an everything bagel slathered with cream cheese with a dash of everything bagel seasoning, to make the perfect BLT bagel sandwich.

14. Avocado Chickpea Salad Sandwich

This bagel is so good, that you won’t even believe it’s vegan!

Extra satisfying and cream, it contains the perfect blend of avocados and chickpeas, even meat eaters will enjoy it.

The beauty of the avocado and chickpea recipe is that it doesn’t require many ingredients, and is customizable with anything you got on hand!

It is an easy way to transform a plain, poppy seed bagel into a hearty, yet healthy meal – it’s dairy-free (see also ‘The Only 33 Dairy-Free Recipes You Will Ever Need‘) and full of delicious flavors.

15. Heirloom Avocado Bagel Witches

If you’re unfamiliar with the term ‘bagelwich’, essentially it combines the words bagel and sandwich which perfectly describes this concoction. 

Heirloom tomatoes are cut into thick slices and piled onto a grainy, chewy bagel with avocado, microgreens, and cream cheese. 

Drizzle some olive oil and a sprinkling of smoked sea salt before serving to make the best lunch ever.

16. Ham And Cheese Bagels

Some days, you’ll want to whip up a five-course meal, however; other days you just want a quick, simple recipe that will satisfy your taste buds. 

For one of those simpler days, why not try this ham and cheese bagel recipe. Grab a plain bagel, and load it with veggies, cheese, and ham for a satisfying yet incredibly easy lunch.

17. Sun Dried Tomato, Sprouts, And Cream Cheese Bagel Sandwich Recipe

Tasty, quick, easy, and filling – this recipe ticks all the boxes!

For a loaded bagel, this recipe calf for juicy, sweet sun-dried tomatoes, layered with rich cream cheese and peppery sprouts for the ultimate breakfast, brunch, or lunch dish.

18. Bagel Tuna Melt

These tuna melts are positively children-friendly (and great for those fussy adults). 

These bagels bring both taste and nutrition onto the take. Not only is it easy to make but is also irresistible with a layer of tuna salad topped with melted cheese.

19. Avocado Tuna Salad Bagel Sandwich

For those tuna salad lovers, meet your new favorite sandwich! This avocado tuna salad bagel sandwich is filled with fresh greens and protein, all served on a whole wheat everything bagel.

With only five minutes needed for preparation, this is the perfect quick and easy lunch that is sure to impress. 

Instead of mayonnaise, you’ll find a rich, creamy blend of avocado and cream cheese, flavored with lime vinaigrette and fresh cilantro. 

Serve with veggies or tortilla chips to complete the meal.

20. Breakfast Fruit Bagel

This is the perfect light and easy breakfast that everyone can enjoy. 

Slather some cream cheese on a whole wheat bagel and heap it with your favorite fruits, transforming boring breakfasts into a healthy and magical meal. 

For this recipe, you’ll need a bright array of fruits such as oranges, berries, and kiwis. Although, the beauty of this recipe is that you can add whatever fruits, or vegetables, you desire!

21. Bagel Thin Pesto Sandwich

If you want the bagel without the carbs, then you’re going to love this recipe. 

With only three ingredients, you’ll be able to create a satisfying meal that works for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. 

Made with zesty pine nut pesto, veggies, and creamy hummus – this bagel provides you with all the flavors and nutrients; guilt-free.

22. Asiago Cheese Bagel Sandwich

If you’re wondering what asiago is, well; it is a type of Italian cheese known for its creamy, mild taste, and crumbly texture. 

It makes for the perfect addition to the bagel’s chunky tomatoes, sliced ham, and fresh lettuce. 

Due to its convenience and ease, it makes for the perfect grab-and-go lunch on busy days.

23. Everything Bagel Grilled Cheese

Transform your regular bagels into these mouthwatering everything bagel grilled cheese recipes! 

All you need is cheddar cheese and fried onions – it’s that simple! 

Only requiring 10 minutes from preparation to eating, you’ll be able to eat this masterpiece in no time.

24. Raisin Bagel Stackers

For the perfect sweet and savory breakfast, you need to try these raisin bagel stackers!

Whether made for breakfast or any other time of the day, they make for an ideal snack that is not only healthy but incredibly delicious. 

Instead of going for a plain or seeded bagel, have you ever tried a raisin and cinnamon bagel? Seriously, don’t knock it until you try it! 

The bagel is packed with cream cheese and turkey filling. And while there are a lot of flavors all in one place, they complement each other perfectly.

25. Pear Apple Cheddar Caramelized Onion Grilled Cheese Bagel Sandwich

Looking for a more adventurous bagel? Want to expand your taste buds? Well, you’re in the perfect place to do so. 

Simply saying its name is a statement! This is a scrumptious grilled cheese bagel loaded with pear, apple, caramelized onion, sunny-side-up egg, arugula, and, of course, more cheese! 

Perfect for those cheat days!

26. Smoked Salmon Bagels

For a classic breakfast, why not try this smoked salmon bagel recipe which takes these bagels up a notch. You won’t be able to look at regular smoked salmon bagels the same way ever again!

These bagels are easy to make and burst with flavors. It’s time to ditch the boring, bland bagels and standard salmon, for this homemade, healthy alternative. 

Packed with piquant capers, a homemade herb cream cheese spread, and smashed, creamy avocado. All these flavors come together to produce a tangy taste. 

If you’re expecting guests for lunch, turn these bagels into a full meal with a side of salad.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is A Bagel Made Of?

Plain bagels are made from a simple mixture that includes salt, yeast, water, and flour. For a fancier bagel, you can also use sugar, seeds, butter, honey, eggs, or barley malt. 

Final Thoughts

Bagels are among the most versatile foods. Whether you are eating them for breakfast, lunch, or dinner – there is a range of different ways you can spice up the traditional bagel recipes.

Hopefully, this guide has informed you all about the different bagel recipes.

26 Mouth-Watering Bagel Sandwich Recipes

26 Mouth-Watering Bagel Sandwich Recipes

Recipe by Jenna

From traditional to the bizarre, we have a great collection of bagel sandwich recipes that will have you salivating.

Course: Dinner
5 from 1 vote
Follow Me
Latest posts by Jenna (see all)